Good Calories, Bad Calories

Master case overview

Master file reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Illustrative status

Approved

Author / reference identity

Gary Taubes

Subject area

Health & Medicine

Work

Good Calories, Bad Calories

Review focus

Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology. Program questions are selected for this subject area; no passage-level findings are asserted.

Proposed formats · scenario

Ebook and library editions

Proposed market scope · scenario

Domestic release with a proposed translation-rights package

Book release date

25 September 2007
Publication history ↗

Registration date · illustrative

2 October 2007

Publication and registration basis

Good Calories, Bad Calories: Title and author matched publication-history record. Original-language/edition differences are retained where specified. The modeled registration is seven days after release. Where a source gives only a month or year, dates are shown as a range rather than inventing a day.

Modeled review date

2 November 2007

Source basis

Library title, author, subject mapping and catalog program definitions; no manuscript examined.

Programs & status

This illustrative file covers 10 program records, 35 review controls and 0 open items. Select a program for its review details, document checklist and next action.

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-HMPC

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

3 of 3 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 3

1. HMPC-101

   Claim classification

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, separate general discussion from diagnostic or treatment claims in the proposed scope. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. HMPC-104

   Reader framing

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, separate educational content from individualized advice. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. HMPC-105

   Evidence updates

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, identify time-sensitive health references for later rechecking. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 3

• Health claim classification ledgerCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: HMPC-101.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Reader information wording sheetCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: HMPC-104.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Health evidence update scheduleCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: HMPC-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-FCRS

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

5 of 5 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 5

1. FCRS-101

   Claim inventory

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, classify factual, historical and statistical claims selected for the review scope. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. FCRS-102

   Source traceability

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, record author, date, edition and location of supporting references. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. FCRS-103

   Context and limitations

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, retain qualifications and avoid widening conclusions beyond their sources. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

4. FCRS-104

   Data reproduction

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, reconcile quoted figures with their source tables and units. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

5. FCRS-105

   Correction control

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, track the edition in which a proposed correction would take effect. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 5

• Claim-to-source ledgerCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: FCRS-101.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Source bibliography and locator indexCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: FCRS-102.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Claim qualification scheduleCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: FCRS-103.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Statistical reproduction worksheetCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: FCRS-104.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Correction and version logCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: FCRS-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-PFVR

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

4 of 4 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 4

1. PFVR-102

   Verification sources

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, identify primary sources needed to verify each credential. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. PFVR-103

   Jurisdiction wording

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, distinguish academic qualifications from jurisdiction-specific practice rights. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. PFVR-104

   Biography consistency

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, align proposed retailer, jacket and speaker biographies. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

4. PFVR-105

   Currency checks

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, identify which professional claims need date-sensitive confirmation. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 4

• Credential verification checklistCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: PFVR-102.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Professional title wording matrixCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: PFVR-103.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Biography comparison sheetCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: PFVR-104.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Credential currency scheduleCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: PFVR-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-AEPC

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

4 of 4 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 4

1. AEPC-101

   Promotional claims

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, match proposed promotional language to documented support. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. AEPC-103

   Material connections

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, identify sponsorship disclosures that would be needed for the campaign. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. AEPC-104

   Excerpt context

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, retain context when selecting extracts for advertising. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

4. AEPC-105

   Campaign versions

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, keep translated campaign copy aligned with the source version. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 4

• Advertising claim matrixCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AEPC-101.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Campaign disclosure scheduleCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AEPC-103.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Promotional excerpt reviewCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AEPC-104.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Campaign version registerCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AEPC-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-IMRC

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

3 of 3 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 3

1. IMRC-102

   Non-affiliation wording

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, review references to people and institutions for unintended endorsement implications. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. IMRC-104

   Edition-specific publicity

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, align retailer summaries and campaign copy with the edition proposed for release. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. IMRC-105

   Escalation protocol

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, define which disputed statements would require specialist review before reuse. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 3

• Non-affiliation wording sheetCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IMRC-102.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Campaign and jacket-copy comparisonCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IMRC-104.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Media review escalation planCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IMRC-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-IDLC

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

3 of 3 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 3

1. IDLC-101

   Agreement inventory

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, identify proposed publisher, distributor and retail permissions for the named work. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. IDLC-102

   License boundaries

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, map term, format, territory, language and sublicensing limits. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. IDLC-104

   Accounting and reporting

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, document royalty reporting intervals, deductions and audit provisions. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 3

• Distribution agreement inventoryCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IDLC-101.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Distribution license matrixCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IDLC-102.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Royalty and reporting scheduleCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IDLC-104.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-IRTC

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

3 of 3 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 3

1. IRTC-103

   Edition history

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, separate original publication rights from revised-edition and supplementary-material rights. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. IRTC-104

   Quotation permissions

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, record the basis for reuse of any third-party extracts in the proposed edition. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. IRTC-105

   Reversion and reservations

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, identify expired grants, reserved uses and conflicting options. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 3

• Edition and rights chronologyCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IRTC-103.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Third-party permissions registerCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IRTC-104.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Prior grants and reversion scheduleCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IRTC-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-CAVR

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

3 of 3 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 3

1. CAVR-101

   Visual asset provenance

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, record the source and permitted use of cover and interior visual assets. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. CAVR-102

   Designer permissions

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, separate designer deliverables from third-party stock and font licenses. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. CAVR-105

   Edition approval

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, track the approved cover version for each proposed edition. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 3

• Cover and artwork provenance registerCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: CAVR-101.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Designer and supplier rights checklistCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: CAVR-102.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Cover version approval logCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: CAVR-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-IBEM

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

3 of 3 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 3

1. IBEM-102

   Authorized channels

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, distinguish approved editions and sellers from items that need verification. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. IBEM-103

   Monitoring exclusions

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, exclude commentary, criticism and other lawful references from proposed monitoring. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. IBEM-105

   Notice readiness

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, specify evidence capture and rights-holder approval before any proposed notice. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 3

• Authorized edition and channel registerCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IBEM-102.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Monitoring keyword and exclusion planCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IBEM-103.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Evidence capture and escalation protocolCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: IBEM-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Program reference

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887-AVRR

Master file

GPRCC-ILL-2007-GT-122887

Review scope

Ebook and library editions

Evidence position

4 of 4 controls complete in scenario

Publication context

Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes · Health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology

Review controls and scoped outcome 4

1. AVRR-101

   Audio grant

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, separate narration and audio distribution rights from print rights. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

2. AVRR-102

   Performer agreement

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, define narrator credit, recording use and permitted reuse. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

3. AVRR-103

   Audio-only material

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, identify proposed introductions, music and other added audio assets. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

4. AVRR-105

   Audio metadata

   For the proposed scope of Good Calories, Bad Calories, align abridgment labels, credits and edition descriptions. Apply this check in the context of health evidence, reader framing and professional terminology.

   Completed · scenario. Submitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope.

Completed requirements 4

• Audio rights matrixCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AVRR-101.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Narrator agreement checklistCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AVRR-102.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Audio asset permission registerCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AVRR-103.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative
• Audio edition metadata sheetCompletedSubmitted evidence accepted; this requirement is completed within the scenario’s approved scope. Reference: AVRR-105.Submission attempt 1 · 7 October 2007 · reviewed 2 November 2007 · illustrative

↑ Back to programs

Evidence and document index

A modeled evidence schedule for Good Calories, Bad Calories. These are document requirements and scenario states, not uploaded attachments or manuscript citations.

Consolidated program status

Illustrative review history

Generated milestones showing how this workflow could progress; these events did not occur for the named author.

Program fee breakdown

The original illustrative case total is allocated across the 10 programs below. These example amounts are not payment receipts or quotations.

Total illustrative fees · USD$28,500

These restored case allocations are separate from the planning bands for new quotes. A written scope and quote determine the charge for an actual matter.

Next steps

1. Retain the edition, format and rights schedules modeled in this record.
2. Check proposed changes against each program’s maintenance standard.
3. Reassess new translations, licenses or substantial promotional changes before extending scope.

This sequence describes the modeled approved workflow only.